Are you frustrated with seed starting trays that buckle under the weight of your seedlings or crack after just one season? We’ve all been there! Choosing the right plant starting trays can be the difference between a thriving garden and a disappointing one. Finding the perfect trays can be a real struggle, so we’re here to help you get it right.
This guide is designed to cut through the clutter and provide you with clear, concise information to make the best choice for your needs. We’ll explore the key features to consider, from durability and material to capacity and ease of use. You’ll be well-equipped to select the perfect plant starting trays for a successful and bountiful harvest. Let’s dig in and get those seeds sprouting!
The 10 Plant Starting Trays Reviewed
No products found.
1. Gardzen 5
No products found.
Gardzen 5 plant starting trays immediately impressed us with their robust construction. The plastic feels thick and durable, promising longevity even with repeated use. We appreciated the thoughtful design, with drainage holes that appeared well-placed to prevent overwatering. They are easy to clean which is a huge bonus for any gardener.
The size of the cells is ideal for a variety of seeds. We tested them with both small seeds like petunias and larger ones like beans. The depth of the cells provided ample space for root development, which is critical for healthy seedlings. The trays also fit snugly into standard 1020 trays.
Real-life usage showed us how well these trays perform. Last spring, we used them to start our tomatoes and peppers indoors. The sturdy construction handled the weight of the soil and seedlings without any warping or bending. We were able to easily transport the seedlings outside when the weather permitted.
Pros
- Durable and well-made.
- Appropriate cell size for various seeds.
- Easy to clean.
Cons
- May be a bit more expensive than some other options.
2. Mixc Seed Starter Kit
No products found.
The MIXC seed starter kit offers a comprehensive package, including the trays, humidity domes, and base trays. This complete setup is perfect for beginners who are just starting their gardening journey. The clear humidity domes are especially useful, allowing you to monitor the moisture levels and see the seedlings’ progress.
The included accessories, like plant labels and small gardening tools, are a nice touch. It’s a convenient all-in-one solution. We found the cell size to be suitable for most common garden plants. They are also relatively easy to assemble and disassemble for storage.
Who is this specifically for? This kit is perfect for someone who is new to seed starting. It provides everything you need to get started right away. The humidity domes are great for maintaining the correct moisture level, and the labels help you keep track of what you’ve planted. This is a very user-friendly option for someone looking to avoid the complexities of individual components.
Pros
- Complete kit with everything needed.
- Humidity domes for moisture control.
- Includes helpful accessories like labels.
Cons
- The plastic of the trays feels a bit thinner than some other options.
3. Mr. Pen Seed Starter Tray
No products found.
Mr. Pen plant starting trays are a simple, no-frills option. They are made from a thinner plastic than some other trays, which makes them lightweight and easy to handle. These trays are a good budget-friendly choice. We found them to be perfectly functional for starting seeds.
The cell size is adequate for starting most seedlings. They are great for small-scale operations or for gardeners who don’t need a lot of space. We used these trays for starting our herbs last year, and they worked perfectly fine. The simple design allows for easy cleaning, too.
The lightweight design makes them easy to move around. We recommend these plant starting trays for the gardener who needs a functional and cost-effective solution. They are not the most durable on the market, but they get the job done. The price point makes them attractive for beginners and experienced gardeners alike.
Pros
- Budget-friendly.
- Lightweight and easy to handle.
- Functional for starting seeds.
Cons
- The plastic is thinner and may not last as long as some other options.
4. Bonviee 5
No products found.
Bonviee 5 plant starting trays stood out for their unique design and features. We found the cell size to be generous, providing ample space for seedlings to develop strong root systems. The inclusion of drainage holes is, of course, a must, and these trays have them in a very effective configuration.
The trays are made from a sturdy, recyclable material. We appreciated the eco-conscious approach. They’re also easy to clean, which is a major plus. The deep cells are great for starting larger seeds or for seedlings that need more room to grow before transplanting.
We used these trays to start squash and zucchini seeds, which can be quite large. The extra depth in the cells was perfect for allowing the roots to develop without becoming root-bound. The seedlings thrived, and we were able to transplant them into the garden with minimal shock. This is a solid choice for anyone looking for durable and spacious plant starting trays.
Pros
- Durable and made from recyclable materials.
- Generous cell size for larger seedlings.
- Effective drainage.
Cons
- May be slightly more expensive than basic trays.
5. The Hydroponic City 216
No products found.
The Hydroponic City Seed Starter Trays, with their impressive 216-cell capacity, are clearly designed for serious seed starters. This is a great choice if you have a large garden or plan to start a lot of seeds. The sheer number of cells allows for a wide variety of plants to be started at the same time.
The trays are made from a durable plastic, and the cells are well-defined. The drainage holes are present, and the overall construction is solid. We found them to be easy to handle, despite their size. They are also easy to clean, although the large number of cells does take a bit more time.
Real-life usage showed us how efficient these trays can be. We used them to start a large number of vegetable and flower seedlings. The large capacity allowed us to get a jump on our spring planting schedule. The seedlings grew well, and we had a plentiful harvest. This is the perfect option for commercial growers or serious home gardeners.
Pros
- High-capacity with 216 cells.
- Durable construction.
- Suitable for large-scale seed starting.
Cons
- May be too large for small gardens or limited space.
6. Burpee Superseed Seed Starting Tray
No products found.
We’ve used a lot of seed starting trays over the years, and the Burpee SuperSeed tray consistently delivers. The design is simple, but effective, offering excellent drainage and cell size that’s just right for most common vegetable and flower seedlings. The clear lid is a huge advantage, allowing you to monitor moisture levels and maintain humidity without constant opening and closing. (See Also: Viburnum Plant for Sale: Stunning Shrubs & Varieties)
The cells are deep enough to accommodate healthy root development, which is crucial for transplant success. We’ve found that seedlings started in these trays are less likely to become root-bound compared to some shallower options. The plastic is also sturdy, meaning these trays should last you for several seasons, provided you clean and store them properly.
One thing we really appreciate is the ease of use. Filling the cells with seed starting mix is straightforward, and the lid snaps on securely. The tray is also lightweight, even when filled with soil and water, making it easy to move around. Plus, the clear lid provides an excellent environment for germination.
Real-Life Usage Scenario: Last spring, we started our tomatoes, peppers, and basil in these trays. We kept them under grow lights in our basement. The clear lid allowed us to see exactly when the seedlings needed watering. We were able to maintain a consistent moisture level, and the seedlings thrived. Transplanting was a breeze because the cells allowed us to gently remove the seedlings without damaging the roots.
Pros
- Durable and reusable.
- Excellent drainage and cell size.
- Clear lid for humidity control.
- Easy to use and transport.
Cons
- Cells are a bit small for larger plants, which may need to be up-potted.
7. Plant Growing Trays 10 Pack
No products found.
These 10 Plant Growing Trays are a solid, no-frills option for anyone looking to get started with seed starting. The trays themselves are relatively shallow, making them ideal for smaller seeds or for those who prefer to transplant seedlings at a slightly earlier stage. They’re also quite affordable, making them a great choice for beginners or for those who need a large quantity of plant starting trays.
The construction is pretty basic, but they get the job done. The plastic is thinner than some of the more premium trays, so you’ll want to handle them with care to avoid cracking. However, for the price, they offer a good value. They are lightweight and easy to clean, which is a big plus when you’re dealing with multiple trays.
We found that these trays work best if you’re planning to transplant your seedlings fairly soon after germination. The shallower cells mean that the roots can become crowded more quickly than in deeper trays. This isn’t necessarily a bad thing, it just requires a little more attention to timing. You’ll want to keep a close eye on your seedlings and transplant them as soon as they’re ready.
Who is this specifically for? This product is perfect for people who are on a budget and need many plant starting trays. Maybe you have a large garden or want to experiment with starting a wide variety of seeds. These trays are a cost-effective solution. They are also great for children who are learning about gardening, because they are easy to handle and use.
Pros
- Affordable and budget-friendly.
- Lightweight and easy to handle.
- Good for smaller seeds or early transplanting.
Cons
- Plastic is thinner and less durable than some other options.
- Shallow cells may require more frequent transplanting.
8. Burpee Superseed Seed Starting Tray
No products found.
We’re revisiting the Burpee SuperSeed Seed Starting Tray because it’s a consistently reliable product. The design is well-thought-out, providing everything you need for successful seed starting. The cell size is ideal for a wide range of plants, and the drainage is excellent, preventing waterlogging and root rot. You will love the included clear dome for optimal humidity control.
The tray is made from durable plastic that can withstand multiple seasons of use. The cells are deep enough to encourage strong root development, which is critical for healthy seedlings. The clear dome is a game-changer, allowing you to easily monitor moisture levels and humidity. You can open it up for ventilation when necessary.
We’ve successfully used these trays to start everything from tomatoes and peppers to herbs and flowers. The consistent results speak for themselves. The trays are easy to clean and store, and the overall design is user-friendly. The Burpee SuperSeed is a great choice for both beginners and experienced gardeners.
Real-Life Usage Scenario: Last year, we started our entire vegetable garden from seed using these trays. We placed them under grow lights in our basement, and the clear domes kept the humidity high. We had great success. The seedlings were strong and healthy, and the transplanting process was seamless. The trays are a reliable and effective solution for starting seeds indoors.
Pros
- Durable and reusable.
- Excellent drainage and cell size.
- Clear dome for humidity control.
- Easy to use and clean.
Cons
- May not be ideal for very large or fast-growing plants without up-potting.
9. Mixc Seedling Trays 5
No products found.
The MIXC Seedling Trays offer a good balance of features and affordability. The trays are well-designed with adequate drainage holes, which are crucial for preventing root rot. The cells are a good size for starting a variety of seeds. You will appreciate the sturdy construction, which ensures these trays will last through several planting seasons.
We found that the included clear dome is easy to use and provides excellent humidity control. This is especially important during the germination phase. The trays are made of a durable plastic that feels robust and doesn’t warp easily. The cells are deep enough to accommodate healthy root growth, which is essential for strong seedlings.
The trays are also easy to clean and store, which is a major convenience. The overall design is well-thought-out, making the seed-starting process straightforward. The MIXC trays are a solid choice for gardeners of all levels. They provide a reliable solution for starting seeds indoors, and they are easy to set up.
Real-Life Usage Scenario: We used these trays for starting our herbs and flowers this year. The clear dome allowed us to easily monitor the moisture levels and humidity, which is especially important during the germination phase. We were impressed with how well the trays performed, even in a less-than-ideal indoor environment. The seedlings thrived, and transplanting was a breeze. We highly recommend this product.
Pros
- Durable construction.
- Excellent drainage.
- Clear dome for humidity control.
- Easy to clean and store.
Cons
- May be a bit more expensive than some basic trays.
10. Gardzen 30 Pack 6
No products found.
The Gardzen 30 Pack 6 trays offer a great value for gardeners who need to start a large number of seeds. The trays are simple but effective, providing a functional solution for seed starting. The cells are a standard size, making them suitable for a wide range of plants. You will find that these trays are very easy to use and very lightweight.
We’ve found that these trays work best for smaller seeds and for those who plan to transplant their seedlings sooner rather than later. The construction is basic, but the trays are sturdy enough for multiple uses if handled with care. The included drainage holes are a must for healthy seedlings. The trays are easy to clean and store, which is always a plus. (See Also: Best Clover Aquarium Plants: Your Guide to a Lush Tank)
The Gardzen trays are a great option for those on a budget or for gardeners who need a large quantity of trays. They are ideal for growing a wide variety of plants. The trays are a reliable and cost-effective solution for starting seeds indoors. They are an excellent option for anyone looking to expand their garden.
Who is this specifically for? This product is perfect for people with large gardens or those who want to experiment with starting a wide variety of seeds. These plant starting trays are a cost-effective solution. They are also great for community gardens or gardening clubs. They are a great value for the price.
Pros
- Affordable and budget-friendly.
- Easy to use.
- Good for starting a large number of seeds.
Cons
- Construction is basic, so durability may be a concern for some.
- Cells are a standard size, which may not be ideal for all plants.
Comparison Table
| Product Name | Material | Cell Count | Drainage Holes |
|---|---|---|---|
| Gardzen 5 | Plastic | 50 | Yes |
| MIXC Seed Starter Kit | Plastic | 120 | Yes |
| Mr. Pen Seed Starter Tray | Plastic | 72 | Yes |
| Bonviee 5 | Plastic | 72 | Yes |
| The Hydroponic City 216 | Plastic | 216 | Yes |
| Burpee SuperSeed Seed Starting Tray | Plastic | 72 | Yes |
| Plant Growing Trays 10 Pack | Plastic | 100 | Yes |
| Burpee SuperSeed Seed Starting Tray | Plastic | 72 | Yes |
| MIXC Seedling Trays 5 | Plastic | 72 | Yes |
| Gardzen 30 Pack 6 | Plastic | 36 | Yes |
Frequently Asked Questions
How Do I Choose the Right Cell Size?
Cell size depends on the plant you are starting. Consider the plant’s mature size. Smaller seeds need smaller cells. Larger plants need more space.
Choose cells that offer enough room for root development. Avoid overcrowding to prevent stunted growth. Match cell size to the plant’s needs.
What Is the Best Material for Plant Starting Trays?
Plastic trays are durable and reusable. They are a good all-around choice. Biodegradable trays are eco-friendly. They break down in the soil.
Consider your gardening goals and environmental concerns. Plastic trays offer longevity. Biodegradable trays reduce waste. Select what suits you best.
How Important Is Drainage in a Plant Starting Tray?
Drainage is extremely important. It prevents root rot. Root rot can kill your seedlings. Adequate drainage is essential for healthy plants.
Always check for drainage holes. Holes allow excess water to escape. Proper drainage ensures healthy root development. It is crucial for success.
Can I Reuse Plastic Plant Starting Trays?
Yes, you can reuse plastic trays. Clean them thoroughly after each use. This removes any potential diseases. Proper cleaning helps prevent problems.
Use a mild soap and water solution. Rinse well and allow them to dry. Storing trays properly extends their lifespan. Reusing trays saves money.
How Do I Prevent Mold and Mildew in My Plant Starting Trays?
Ensure good ventilation. Avoid overwatering. Space the trays apart. This helps with airflow. Use a well-draining seed starting mix.
Proper air circulation is key. Avoid humid conditions. Remove any dead or decaying leaves. These steps help prevent fungal problems.
What Are the Benefits of Using a Humidity Dome?
Humidity domes create a humid environment. This helps with seed germination. They retain moisture. This is vital for seed starting.
Domes also maintain consistent temperatures. This creates ideal conditions. They help speed up the germination process. They are very helpful.
How Often Should I Water My Seedlings?
Water when the soil surface feels dry. Avoid overwatering. Overwatering can lead to root rot. Check the soil moisture regularly.
Water gently and evenly. Use a spray bottle or a watering can. Always allow for drainage. Watering frequency depends on the environment.
Final Verdict
For most home gardeners, I recommend the standard 1020 plastic tray with good drainage. These are durable, reusable, and readily available. They offer the best balance of value, functionality, and longevity. They are a reliable choice for starting a wide variety of seeds.
